Of these three silent era releases from Kino, The Vanishing American is definitely the least known. However, it has weathered the past 70+ years better than either Uncle Tom's Cabin or Peter Pan. Like Uncle Tom's Cabin, it's handicapped by the casting, which places a white man in an Indian role; however, in many other respects The Vanishing American is a remarkably forward thinking view of how Indians have been mistreated by the white man. The drama even casts many authentic Indians in supporting roles. (This was actually a relatively common practice in the silent era.) While '50s movies such as Broken Arrow and The Devil's Doorway have received credit as depicting Indian characters with sensitivity, The Vanishing American served the same function over a quarter century previously.
The movie begins as a broad-scale panorama of American Indian history, taking us back to the first very first Indians in North America and then supplying brief vignettes of each major historical era. We see the Basket-Makers, the Slab-House People, the Cliff Dwellers, the arrival of Spanish explorers, and the onslaught of U.S. cavalry soldiers. After 30 minutes of historical background, the movie begins to tell the story of an Indian named Nophaie (Richard Dix), who lives on a reservation along with the Indians of his tribe. On the reservation, the white men take advantage of them. In one scene, a crooked government agent (Noah Beery) insists the Indians bring their horses into town as contributions to the American war effort in WWI. However, the agent has no intention of handing the horses over to the military. He sells the horses and pockets the money.
The movie rather coyly works out a romantic attraction between Nophaie and a schoolteacher (Lois Wilson). This is one of the movie's weakest developments. Critic John Grierson railed against The Vanishing American when it was released in 1926, saying the movie failed because the director hadn't "the courage to let the love story run its course." And to a certain extent, he is right. The schoolmistress becomes a generic Western heroine--"just another of these Hollywood smilers," Grierson writes. And Dix is not permitted to "make love to the lady at all except by innuendo, by bringing along flowers and calling the lady 'little white rose,' etc. etc."
The Vanishing American does fail at becoming an epic historical tale, for it dissolves into small-scale B-movie dramatics. But it's a wonderfully entertaining movie nonetheless. It might fail to reach its lofty goals as a portrait of the passing of the Indian, but director George B. Seitz and screenwriter Ethel Doherty have fashioned a story that firmly places its allegiances with the American Indian and dares to show how government agents took advantage of the people they were supposedly protecting. But most successfully, it shows Indians joining the American military and fighting for a country that hardly recognizes them as citizens. When they return, they meet complete indifference and discover their lands have been stolen.
For anyone who thinks John Ford discovered Monument Valley, look no further than The Vanishing American for evidence otherwise. Seitz makes extensive use of the buttes and open spaces of Monument Valley, particularly in the movie's opening half hour as he chronicles the history of Indians in North America.
The Vanishing American is currently only available on VHS; however, Kino promises to release it on DVD in the near future.