Scott's next theatrical film appearance was as prosecuting attorney Claude Dancer in Otto Preminger's Anatomy of a Murder (1959), where he gave a strong performance, holding his own with such veterans as Jimmy Stewart. "They originally wanted me to play the bartender," Scott said, "but I told them I wanted to play the guy from Lansing. So, they gave me that part, and Murray Hamilton ended up playing the bartender. He was a dear friend; I miss him a lot."